Friday, 18 September 2015

Jeremy Corbyn’s democratic challenge


What will Jeremy Corbyn’s stunning victory in Labour’s leadership election mean for us in Wales? What are the chances he can mobilise progressive forces across the political spectrum and provide leadership for a real change of direction for the economy away from austerity?

He has certainly galvanized ordinary members to mount an insurgency against the tired economic thinking of their party at Westminster. But can he continue the momentum to reach out to the nations beyond London and to those outside his party? A lot hangs on the answer to that question. If he gets sucked into political infighting within the Labour Party at Westminster, as the right wing media would love him to do, he will be lost.

During the campaign Caroline Lucas the Greens’ sole MP at Westminster gave him some sound advice. She observed that it was a hardly a coincidence that the first truly democratic leadership election in Labour’s history was producing such a resurgence of optimism. However, she was disappointed that Corbyn was giving so little emphasis to democracy more widely: “If you do win this contest I believe you should take this opportunity – and the huge amount of momentum behind you – to call a constitutional convention to allow people across the country to have a say in remodelling Britain for the future,” she wrote in The Independent on 13 September. “A convention has the potential to energise even more people than your leadership campaign, or the Green surge, and to inspire the kind of feeling across the UK that swept Scotland in 2014.”

I have looked for what Jeremy Corbin has said on this during his campaign, and found very little, save one interview he gave the online Novara TV website on 30 July. In it he said he was in favour of the additional member proportional system that operates for the Welsh Assembly to be used for the House of Commons and also for PR for a directly elected House of Lords. And he continued: “I want to see a constitutional convention set up now in Opposition that would look at the issues of electoral representation, the voting age, the voting system… We also want to look at the question of the different powers and financing of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, the operation of the Barnett formula and whether or not it wouldn’t be better based on levels of poverty in Scotland rather than more generally on population and area, and at the question of English regional government.”


This is fine as far as it goes. But these ideas can hardly be said to be central to Jeremy Corbyn’s thinking. Otherwise they would have featured much more widely than on an obscure online current affairs website early in the campaign. Certainly he has said little, if anything, on this score during the first few days since being elected as leader. Nonetheless, this agenda will be a litmus test for whether Jeremy Corbyn is interested in creating an effective coalition for progressive politics beyond the narrow confines of his own party.

Friday, 11 September 2015

Leanne Wood’s vision for Wales


Leanne Wood has been touring Wales this week to launch Plaid’s campaign for next May’s Assembly election. After 16 years of a Labour government in Cardiff Bay she says it’s time for a change and that Plaid can offer better policies on the economy, health and education.

To succeed she has to persuade voters that she would be an effective First Minister. She certainly has recognition. As a result of the television debates in the general election this year she became a household name across the UK, and mobbed on the streets from Carmarthen and Wrexham to her native Rhondda. Polling after the election gave her a higher visibility than Carwyn Jones, the current First Minister - 78 per cent recognition against his 74 per cent.

Electing an English speaker from the Valleys as leader in 2012 marked a distinct departure for Plaid Cymru. Living in the same Penygraig street as she was born, she is as far from the party’s rural Welsh-speaking heartlands as it is possible to be.
 
Born in 1971 she was educated at Tonypandy Grammar School and the University of Glamorgan. In the 1990s she worked as a probation officer in Mid Glamorgan before becoming a lecturer in Social Policy at Cardiff University. She was first elected to the Assembly in 2003.

Why did she join Plaid in 1991, aged 20, rather than Labour? She says that when she was growing up in the Rhondda the local Labour Party came across as right wing and reactionary, or as she put it: “Sexist, homophobic – and just generally representing old-fashioned dinosaur politics, which in my view had no place in my life.” More fundamental was her teenage experience of the 1984-5 miners strike. “It had a profound effect on me, to be honest,” she said. “When you live through a historical period you don’t realise it, but looking back now I can see that.”

She has an eye for practical policy innovation. Opponents said her call for a tax on sugary drinks to combat diabetes and obesity was impractical, but it has now been taken up by the BMA

Leanne is a departure for Plaid Cymru because of her emphasis on a modern, inclusive sense of who we are. “All people have a stake here, if they live here,” she says. “Nationality and identity - those kinds of questions - are not really important from a political perspective.”


She has two aspirations for Wales. First she wants to see Plaid Cymru leading the Welsh Government after the Assembly election. Then her priority will be putting the economy on its feet.  After that she says it will be up to the people to decide: “I think most people in Wales want to see improvements in our economy before being able to contemplate voting yes in a referendum on greater self government.” That she says involves building a new Britain, involving co-operation between England, Scotland and Wales on the basis of equality and shared interests in common.

Friday, 4 September 2015

Slurry threat to Blue Flag beaches


Pembrokeshire’s Blue Flag beaches, so important for the county’s image and tourist offer, are under threat from Welsh Government environmental regulations imposed at the behest of the European Union. How could such a situation have come about? You might well ask. Bear with me, for this is a complicated tale.

Every four years the Cleddau river catchment, which covers about 80 per cent of Pembrokeshire’s land area, is tested for nitrates that are largely caused by farm waste flowing into the water system. If they are too high they cause the growth of algae and other harmful organisms. In turn this upsets the fish and plant life that depend on the health of the waters in Milford Haven and the Marine Special Conservation Area beyond.

When the rivers were last tested in 2012 the nitrate levels almost reached the point where the Welsh Government would have been obliged to impose severe restrictions. As Ged Davies, Pembrokeshire Team Leader for Natural Resources Wales told me, “It was too close to call.”

If a Nitrates Vulnerable Zone had been declared it would have had a massive impact on the 1,800 farms that operate within the river catchment area. There would have been severe limits on the amount of muck spreading, a requirement for much greater winter slurry storage capacity, a clamp down on fertilizers, and strict record keeping of nitrate discharges.

It now looks inevitable that all this will be demanded following the latest measurement of nitrate levels. A report goes to the Welsh Government in October and it will make an announcement early next year with the likely imposition of a Nitrates Zone from the beginning of 2017.

If this happens farmers will be faced with a stark choice: to either reduce the livestock on their land and consequently their income, or increase the amount of land for muck spreading. Many will opt for the latter and look first to buying or renting land immediately adjacent to the Nitrates Zone. The problem is that much of this is next to the coast. As Ged Davies says, “The land outside the Nitrate Vulnerable Zone would likely be in the coastal fringe, in the National Park, and draining to bathing waters. This land would be available for unregulated and potential over applications of slurry. This could have the unforeseen effect of the Nitrates Directive adversely affecting the Bathing Water Directive.”

Hence the threat to EU designated Blue Flag beaches that is coming from EU environmental regulations. So what can be done? One option is for farmers to work with Natural Resources Wales on a voluntary basis to reduce their nitrate output. Ged Davies points to a successful scheme that has operated in recent years among farmers supplying the First Milk cheese processing plant at Merlins Bridge.


If initiatives of this kind could be undertaken across Pembrokeshire there is a chance we could avoid the imposition of a Nitrate Vulnerable Zone in 2017 and the unintended consequences that would be likely to follow for our Blue Flag beaches. But for that to happen there should be an injection of urgency with action taken now.

Friday, 28 August 2015

Solva works cultural miracle


 A remarkable story of community engagement and enthusiasm came to a head last weekend with the celebration of the Edge Festival, Solva’s inaugural carnival of the arts, food, sport, swimming, music, drinking and much else. It is so-called because Solva lies on the rim of Wales, at the brink of the ocean. As our late, great historian John Davies once said, it is “the most delectable place in coastal Pembrokeshire”.

The festival was definitely edgy, and a bit nervous because nobody knew how it would work out. It was ambitious, held over four days in multiple venues with a wide range of participants, from writers, poets and comedians, to actors, surfers and celebrity chefs.

It was certainly damp. It rained everyday, sometimes all day. Yet despite that multiple events went ahead. A high point came with a four-kilometre open water swim from the harbor out to Green Scar rock in St Brides Bay that attracted entrants from across the UK. There was a six-a-side football tournament, rock and folk bands, cookery demonstrations, a pig roast and food of all kinds, plus a concert with Meic Stevens, one of Solva’s most famous sons. In all there were 221 swimmers, 41 musicians, 70 footballers, 40 climbers, hundreds of filmgoers, and drinkers galore. In short, and in defiance of the weather, it was a great success. To the surprise of the pessimistic it even broke even, despite costing upwards of £20,000.

Which is a lot of money for a small community of scarcely more than 1,000 people. How did they manage it? How did the Edge Festival come about and why was it such a success?

In June and July last year Solva was invaded by a film crew remaking Under Milk Wood, Dylan Thomas’s radio play that was first filmed in 1972, starring Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor and using Llangrannog as a backdrop. The new version stars Rhys Ifans, and Charlotte Church, with dozens of Solva villagers hired as extras. For two months the place was transformed. At the end of the shoot, during the wrap party in The Ship Inn, it was decided that Solva’s new cultural profile had to be continued in some way, and so the idea for the Edge Festival was born.

But to make it happen they first had to raise money. Some support came from local businesses and organisations like Literature Wales and the Milford Haven Port Authority, but far from enough. So Solva set to and organised a series of fundraisers including an Italian Supper and a Spanish Feast at the Café on the Quay and a six-course dinner at the Ship Inn to mark the end of the Six Nations tournament. With these and other events, including a raffle, they aimed to raise £10,000. By the end they got to £18,000.


Solva’s Edge Festival has mobilised a whole community and worked wonders for the local economy. It has demonstrated how from small beginnings, with dedication and commitment, something truly ground breaking can be achieved. Watch out for next year.

Friday, 21 August 2015

How about a Pembrokeshire Pound


Here’s a thought: why don’t we launch a Pembrokeshire Pound? The idea would be to have a community-based currency to keep more money circulating in the county for the benefit of local businesses.

If we had a Pembrokeshire pound that could be only used within the county we’d generate more locally-based economic activity. So, for example, a restaurant would be encouraged to buy more homegrown produce. In turn farmers, paid in Pembrokeshire Pounds, would be encouraged to use the currency to pay a local architect, who also dealt in Pembrokeshire Pounds, to design a property renovation. In this way money would keep on circulating locally to the benefit of local independent businesses, producing a multiplier effect. In contrast, economists calculate that for every pound sterling you spend in a M0rrisons or Tesco, more than 80p immediately leaves the county.

The idea is not so far fetched as you might imagine. Local pounds are already operating successfully in a number of English towns, including Totnes, Lewes, Brixton and Stroud, with Exeter coming on stream next month. The most successful local pound was launched in Bristol three years ago. The system works by people exchanging their sterling for paper Bristol Pounds – in single, five, ten and twenty denominations – or by opening an account at the Bristol Credit Union. The currency can then be spent in participating businesses, or between businesses, in return for goods or services.

So far about £1m Bristol Pounds have been issued with £B700,000 still in circulation. More than 800 businesses accept the alternative currency and more than a thousand users have a Bristol Pound account. The rules are straightforward. Businesses have to be locally owned and cannot be listed on the stock exchange. Individuals who participate have to live inside the boundaries of the city defined by the postcode map.

Bristol City Council and other organisations offer their employees part of their salaries in Bristol Pounds. George Ferguson, the city’s mayor, accepts his entire salary (£51.000) in Bristol Pounds. Since June energy bills can be paid in £Bs to the renewable energy provider Good Energy. It claims to be a world first for enabling the paying of energy bills using a local currency.

The Bristol Pound is managed by the non-profit Bristol Pound Community Interest Company in collaboration with the Bristol Credit Union and the city council. Every physical £1 converted to a printed £B1 is backed in a secure trust fund.


The scheme operates through paper notes, which act as local flyers advertising the local economy, and digitally as well. The amount of money circulating in Bristol is still at a fairly low level, though earlier this year a local architecture firm billed the council for £B900,000. As Ciaran Mundy, co-founder of the Bristol Pound, said, “If we can get that kind of procurement going using the currency then we will begin to have a serious impact on the local economy.” If they can do it in Bristol, why not in Pembrokeshire?