Friday, 16 October 2015

Plaid’s vision for a 21st Century NHS


There is better integration of health and social care in agriculture than in the Welsh NHS is the view of Ceredigion AM Elin Jones. She was Minister for Rural Affairs in the coalition government in Cardiff Bay between 2007 and 2011 and for the last four years she has been Plaid’s Shadow Health Minister. Comparing her two roles in an important speech on the future of the NHS last week she said, “Farmers do the social care bit, and vets do the health care – and they do it in an integrated, effective way – even in times of crisis.”

Elin has put her finger on an urgent question that will touch the life of everybody reading this column. What happens to us when we reach older age? In the middle of the last century the NHS was designed for people of working age. Today’s problems of coping with large numbers of confused, ill and vulnerable older people didn’t exist then, simply because most people didn’t live into their eighties. Elin is right when she says we must fundamentally redesign the NHS to take account of this change.

She has come up with a costed plan that will abolish all social care charges for older people in three stages over two Assembly terms. A Plaid-led government would introduce free personal care for older people within two years, at a cost of £32 million. Within five years charges for people with a dementia diagnosis – including those for nursing and residential care - would be abolished, at a cost of £134 million. And all social care charges would be abolished within the second term of a Plaid government, at a remaining cost of £60 million. These commitments will be in Plaid’s manifesto for next year’s Assembly election.

Plaid would create a Community NHS, led by local authorities to be responsible for GP surgeries, community nursing teams and health professionals, community hospitals, mental health services, and adult social care. At the same time a single National Health Board would be created to run Wales’s 20 acute and specialist hospitals. The present Health Boards, including Hywel Dda, would be abolished. We do not need eight of them, together with their chief executives and management teams, to run an effective secondary care health service for a nation of just three million people.

What benefits would be gained from these changes? First, budgets for primary, community and social care would be protected. At present they are decided by the Health Boards and have to compete with the demands of the acute and specialist hospitals. The Health Boards, including our own, have consistently cut GP funding, the most effective front line against people requiring hospital treatment.


Second, out-of-hospital care, especially for the elderly, would be planned seamlessly and democratically. Third, the National Health Board would put in place a strategic and fair service for the Welsh population as a whole, ensuring that everyone can be reached by the emergency services within a reasonable time. As Elin says, “Our acute hospitals would continue to serve their localities and we would guarantee that every part of Wales would remain with an hour’s reach of life saving services.” For Pembrokeshire this would guarantee the continued provision of emergency services, including maternity care, at Withybush.

Friday, 9 October 2015

Puffin shuttle’s passport to paradise

Pembrokeshire's Puffin shuttle in action

For me summer always ends precisely on 27 September, the date that marks the end of the Puffin Shuttle’s daily forays around the Pembrokeshire coast. After that it can only be hailed on Thursdays and Saturdays during its winter schedule travelling between St Davids and Marloes.

The Puffin Bus travels a meandering route along St Bride’s Bay to the benefit of the walkers of the county’s glorious coastal path. First thing it sets out from St David’s, calling at Solva, Newgale, Nolton, Druidston, Broad Haven and Little Haven, and St Brides, coming to a halt at Marloes before returning to St Davids.

For me it is a passport for my favourite occupation of walking this stretch of the coastal path. Over the past 30 years and more I reckon I must have hiked it well over 500 times. I have walked it so often that it appears regularly in my dreams. If I can’t get to sleep I imagine I’m striding out on a particular section and count the landmarks before dropping off.

There is something magical where the sea meets the land, sky and weather in an ever-changing vista. Partly it is the light that, in my experience, is only matched on the west coast of Ireland and along the Lleyn peninsula in north Wales. It explains why Pembrokeshire is home to so many artists.

Spring is a joy when the whites, blues, pinks and reds of the wild flowers and the bright yellow of the gorse carpet the land with a veritable rainbow of colour. At the height of summer the tall grass and hot damp air deliver a heady experience better than any beverage I know. Even in winter walking in the gales that hammer the coast is an exhilarating thing to do. Rough seas, dark threatening clouds and driving rain will transport you from the day to day. 

Walking the path on a regular basis inevitably reveals the permanent inhabitants. The bird life is extraordinarily varied. Apart from the swooping seabirds there are finches, tits, and curlews, plus the occasional wren, robin and blackbird. The best place for skylarks is St Brides where if you lie in the grass for long enough you’ll see them against the sky before they plummet to the earth.

Rabbits are common. Occasionally a badger appears. Late one evening I was startled by one in Bluebell Wood near Little Haven. I don’t know who was most taken aback, he (or she) or me. For a split second we stared at each other before the badger dived into the scrub below. At this time of year you might see a newly born seal pup in a closed stony inlet anywhere along the southern part of the coast. Once I caught a glimpse of a line of dolphins, from a cliff north of Broad Haven, skimming through the water with their dorsal fins occasionally breaking surface.

So as autumn turns to winter and the days ahead are shortening, I’m looking forward to 3 May next year when the Puffin Shuttle begins its schedule seven days a week and summer begins.


Friday, 2 October 2015

Questions Dr Trounce should answer

 “We heard of no serious clinical incidence that has occurred as a result of the changes.” This is what Dr John Trounce, a Consultant Paediatrician in Brighton who chaired the Review Team that looked into the removal of consultant-led maternity services from Withybush to Carmarthen a year ago, told the Hywel Dda Health Board meeting in Llanelli last week.

This emphatic reassurance added to the claim made in the report itself: “We found services in general to be safe with improving outcomes and better compliance with professional standards.”

Yet the report largely discounts the 830 responses the Review Team received from members of the public. Which is extraordinary given that Sue Eardly, the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health’s Head of Reviews, described the number as “a massive response”.

So at the meeting of the Hywel Dda Health Board in Llanelli’s Prince Phillip Hospital on Thursday last week, I asked the Board’s chair Bernadine Rees whether, as a member of the public, I could be allowed to ask Dr Trounce a question. Reluctantly she allowed me one.

“Are you expecting us to believe that out of the 830 responses you received not one, not even one, led you to question whether there have been any safety issues with the removal of consultant led maternity care and the Special Care Bay Unit from Withybush Hospital to Glangwili in Carmarthen?” I asked. 

I observed a look of consternation bordering on panic pass across Dr Trounce’s face as I put this question. He claimed that all the responses were taken fully into account before stalling and referring to Sue Eardley who was sitting alongside him.

The concerns articulated in the responses were “colourful” and “felt emotionally” was the way she put it. Then she added: “In terms of outcomes there were three incidents that were serious.”

It is clear that the Review Team largely dismissed the public responses they received directly in response to their call for evidence. Their report sidelines the worries about safety they heard as merely being “fear of the unknown”. Instead they prefer to rely on data collected by the Hywel Dda Health Board itself. “The picture of actual patient experience gathered by the Health Board is significantly more positive that that expressed by campaigners in the social and mainstream media or at public meetings,” says the Review report.

That is hardly surprising. After all the Health Board could not be expected to highlight criticisms of itself. But not only that the report attacks the public who have been responding. It refers to “negative messages from the well organised public lobby” which, it says, have been inadequately countered by the Health Board. The result, it claims, is that many staff were left “feeling unsupported and anxious”.

If Bernadine Rees had allowed me some more questions I would have asked Dr Trounce whether he personally had analysed all the 830 public responses he received? Did he think of speaking to any of those people whose experience suggested safety issues had arisen? We need answers to these questions. Meanwhile anyone who thinks the submission they made to the Review Team ought to receive wider circulation should send it to the Pembrokeshire Herald.

Friday, 25 September 2015

The secret life of Billy Lang


One damp chilly morning last week a small group of us met at the Parc Gwyn crematorium near Narberth to say goodbye to Billy Lang, one of our Plaid members in Preseli. It was not an altogether sad occasion because Billy, who hailed from Fishguard, had lived a good life for a full 92 years. But there was something touching about the event all the same, because in a real sense we were Billy’s family. He was an only child, his parents died long ago in the 1960s, he never married, and as far as we know he had no other close relatives.

On the face of it Billy was one of those thousands of people who live their lives without disturbing the surface of public affairs. But it transpires that he had a secret war record. Aged 18 he joined the RAF in 1940 and became a Leading Aircraftman, working with ground crew in the UK and Egypt. Very soon, however, he joined the Special Services Brigade with which he served for much of the Second World War and was only demobbed in 1946. However, mystery surrounds what Billy got up to during this time as he hardly ever spoke about it.

After the war Billy worked on farms, at Trecwn and for a time was a lineman (pole climber) for the South Wales Electricity Board. Aged 37 the 1950s he became a deckhand with trawlers working out of Lowestoft and Milford Haven. After a few years he enrolled as an Able Seaman and later Bosun in a succession of merchant vessels.

For 27 years Billy criss-crossed the oceans of the world. He sailed the Pacific in ships from a Scots owned line. He worked out of Bristol down the coast of West Africa, to Cape Town and then on to Australia. He served on ore carriers that brought iron ore into Port Talbot. He sailed across the Mediterranean, through the Suez Canal and down the coast of East Africa. In 1982 he was on a ship in the South Atlantic carrying water supplies to the forces that recaptured the Falklands. His last voyages before he retired in 1987 were on large container ships owned by Canadian Pacific that plyed the North Atlantic. At least three of the vessels he sailed on later sank. Sop Billy was a lucky man to sail with. 

He was extremely fit, strong and resourceful. He was also a very private man and fiercely independent, characteristics that were almost his undoing. After a fall in his Fishguard bungalow on the Thursday before the August Bank Holiday in 2012 he lay on the floor until the postman heard his cries the following Tuesday. Sipping water from a hot water bottle that had been near his bed and with a bag of nuts to hand Billy, as ever, had a ‘plan to survive’ and it worked. 


Friends who recently applied for his Service Record from the Armed Forces archive in Glasgow were told they would have to wait for 25 years. So it’ll be a long time before we know what Billy really did in the war.