Friday, 17 July 2015

Council faces legal blizzard on schools


Pembrokeshire county council’s secondary schools reorganisation policy is in a mess. On 13 July it was due to publish its proposals following a wide-ranging public consultation that has lasted most of this year. Three days later the full council was to vote on them. Then, on 9 July with only days to go, the Council put the whole process off until September, pending discussions with the Trustees of the Tasker Milward and Picton charity.

What does all this mean? In brief the Council wants to merge Tasker Millward and Sir Thomas Picton secondary schools in Haverfordwest and create a new English-medium and a new Welsh-medium secondary school in the town. On that there is wide agreement. However, the Council also wants the new English-medium school to be just for 11-16-year-olds and provision for sixth-formers made in a new Centre at Pembrokeshire College in Haverfordwest. This would also serve St David’s and Fishguard whose secondary schools would also lose their sixth forms.

These proposals have run into a storm of opposition. It is safe to say that when an authority manages to mobilise entire communities against its policy it has either failed to communicate effectively, failed to listen, or lost the argument.

As it happens, the same day the Council announced it was putting off a decision I was at Sir Thomas Picton School listening to the case in favour of retaining the sixth forms. The main audience was meant to be Pembrokeshire’s 60 county councillors but only a handful turned up and 37 didn’t even reply to their invitations – a case of a failure to listen?

It was the pupils who made by far the most impressive part of the case. We heard a performance by the school’s jazz band and an excerpt from The Sound of Music that was currently in production. Both were excellent and plainly benefited from participation of the schools’ wide age range, from 11 to 19. 

However, what rapidly became clear was that the if the Council presses ahead with removing the sixth forms it will run into a blizzard of legal challenges that could put off its plans for years. In the first place it has failed to square its proposals with the Tasker Milward and Picton Trust which owns most of the Tasker Milward site and is determined to support the continuance of 11-19 education there.

More generally, there were accusations that the Council came to a conclusion about its policy 18 months before the public consultations began, evidenced by documents uncovered through Freedom of Information requests. These, it is alleged, show Pembrokeshire College keen to take over the sixth forms to secure its funding base. As for the Council it is alleged that it wants to offload responsibility for post-16 education to maintain the lowest council tax in Wales. If these accusations prove to be the case the Council deserves to be in the mess it now finds itself in.

In a combative address to the meeting I attended, Paul Lucas, Chairman of Sir Thomas Picton Governors, declared the Council could face an investigation into possible mal-administration following the loss of thousands of pounds as a result of irregular consultation procedures. And he added, “This could be the final death knell of the Council itself, limiting its influence in any future local government reorganisation.” Unfortunately, it is secondary education in Pembrokeshire that could lose out as well.

Friday, 10 July 2015

Give the nation a bird


Nearly a quarter of a million people across Britain have been taking part in a ballot to elect a ‘national’ bird in the past few months. Now don’t get me wrong, in principle I think this is a perfectly good idea. Many countries have such birds, the US the bald eagle, for example, France the rooster, Sweden the blackbird, Japan the green pheasant, and India the peacock.

But it seems a bit odd, in this era of devolution and sporting teams for Scotland, England and Wales, to talk about a ‘national’ bird for Britain. In any event, given the weighting of the population, we’ve inevitably ended up with a national bird for England.

It is, of course, the robin, well known as being territorial, chirpy, and aggressive to other birds. What does that say about ‘national’ character? Birdwatcher and blogger David Lindo, who had the idea for a national bird, attributed the robin’s success to Britain’s small island mentality.

So I think we need a national bird for Wales, a project that should be taken up by the National Assembly. But what bird should it be?

David Lindo organised a committee of experts who came up with a long list of 60 British birds which they whittled down to ten for the online vote. Four were common garden ones – the blackbird, blue tit, wren, and the triumphant robin. The others were a bit more exotic: the threatened hen harrier  (only three pairs bred in 2014), the barn owl, the mute swan, kingfisher, red kite, and puffin.

Pembrokeshire's Puffin should be Wales' national bird

It is interesting that the last two - ones most distinctively associated with Wales – came pretty well down the pecking order. At the top the robin had 75,523 votes. The red kite came fifth, with 13,922, and the puffin came in at tenth, with just 10,674 votes. I wonder how many of those were from Wales.

The red kite is pretty well qualified to be our national bird. Elegantly beautiful, it has a wingspan of up to two metres, a forked tail and chestnut red feathers flecked with white. Persecution meant it nearly became extinct at the end of the 19th Century, only hanging on in deep mid Wales where their numbers fell to a few pairs. At that point a few dedicated landowners began a fight back. For the past few decades Chris and Dominque Powell at Gigrin Farm in the Elan Valley have been running a feeding centre for the birds. Today the red kite is relatively common.

For me, however, the quintessential Welsh bird is the noble, if eccentric, puffin. Equally at home on sea or land, it is given to binge feeding when the seasons allow, though it is also capable of living in tough conditions – puffins spend their winters out in the North Atlantic. And, of course, they inhabit superior and beautiful locations, none more so than Skomer Island off Pembrokeshire. Here you can find about 6,000 breeding pairs at this time of year, one of the largest and most concentrated colonies in the world. Puffins generally live for about 25 years, with Skomer’s record being 38. Now that’s a pretty good qualification to be our national bird.

Friday, 3 July 2015

Purt’s policies that undermine the NHS


A few weeks ago the daughter of a friend of mine, in her twenties, developed severe abdominal pains and found herself at the A&E department of Withybush hospital. The waiting room was packed with holidaymakers and it was clear that the staff were at the end of their tether. She waited five hours.

By the time she was eventually seen the pains had subsided. She was told that she should have been sent to Glangwili in Carmarthen and was given the choice of either making her own way there or going home. She went home.

While she was at Withybush she got talking to an elderly man with a back injury. He also sat in pain for hours without being seen. Eventually his wife went to complain. She was told there were not enough staff on duty to cope with everyone since no special provision had been made for the summertime boost to the local population.

I relate this not to criticise the medical staff at Withybush. They are doing their best in extremely trying circumstances. Rather, the episode illustrates once again how essential it is to retain our hospital services in Pembrokeshire, and especially those that deal with emergency care.

Yet our essential services are steadily being chipped away. Last year we lost the Special Care Baby Unit and mothers are being directed to Carmarthen to have their babies. Paediatric cover is being reduced. Consultants at the hospital are warning that 24-hour A&E is under threat.

All this is happening as a result of decisions made by the Welsh Government in Cardiff, to save money by centralising basic services away from the scattered rural populations of west and north Wales. Welsh Health Minister Mark Drakeford operates at arms length in pursuing this policy, delegating powers to the Health Boards. Nevertheless, he is responsible for the key appointments and overall strategy.

This was made transparent a few weeks ago when he was forced to put the failing north Wales Betsi Cadwaladr Health Board into ‘special measures’ - that is, direct rule. As part of this process the Board’s chief executive Trevor Purt was suspended.

Until last summer when he was sent to north Wales Trevor Purt had been chief executive of the Hywel Dda Health Board for five years. He is responsible for the downgrading of Withybush, appointed in 2009 for precisely this purpose. Before that he was involved in centralising services in northwest England. Between 2003 and 2006 he oversaw the merger of the Rochdale and Heywood Middleton Primary Care Trusts and introduced private sector treatment centres. This prompted the chairwoman of the Trust Debbie Abrahams to resign claiming that Purt’s policies were “destroying the NHS”.

Unsurprisingly, Trevor Purt’s short tenure at Betsi Cadwaladr was dogged by controversy. Plans to shut down a maternity unit were met with massive demonstrations. As the Herald commented when it reported his suspension: “wherever Trevor Purt goes recruitment problems, protests, closures, and controversy are not far behind.” How can we have faith in the Welsh Health Minister’s reassurances about the NHS when he appoints people like Trevor Purt?

Friday, 26 June 2015

Schools compromise on cards for county


All is not well with Pembrokeshire’s secondary education. The headline problems are these: Pupil attainment at GCSE in Pembrokeshire is ranked at sixteenth among the 22 Welsh counties when it should be eighth, on the basis of the socio-economic background. Meanwhile, there are 1,500 surplus secondary school places across the county, making a reorganisation necessary to save money. If the council does not act to correct these problems the Welsh Government will act for it. In January the council proposed the following changes:

  •  Merge Tasker Millward and Sir Thomas Picton secondary schools in Haverfordwest and create a new 11-16 English-medium secondary school on the Sir Thomas Picton site.
  •  Create a new Sixth Form Centre at the Pembrokeshire College campus in Haverfordwest.
  • Remove the sixth forms from Ysgol Bro Gwaun in Fishguard and Ysgol Dewi Sant in St Davids, re-designate them as 11-16 schools, and transfer their post-16 provision to the new Sixth Form Centre.
  •  Create a new Welsh-medium 11-16 secondary school in Haverfordwest at the Tasker Millward site.

 Some of these changes were readily agreed, in particular combining the two English-medium schools and creating a new Welsh-medium school in Haverfordwest. However, there has been uproar at the proposal for removing sixth form provision from the schools and centralising it at the proposed Centre at Pembrokeshire College.

The council has pressed the advantages of the sixth form college concept which, it claims, delivers better results. This has been bitterly contested by the schools, parents and pupils. According to Sir Thomas Picton’s head, Dr N. Poole, the row has led to an atmosphere of anxiety and distrust “borne out by claims and counter claims concerning results, class sizes, university admissions etc without clear transparent data being issued for everyone to view.”

There has been an impressive community-based campaign in St Davids to retain its sixth form. Schools for the Future has come up with an innovative scheme to establish, in effect, a federalised sixth form linking Fishguard, St David’s and Haverfordwest. Some subjects would be taught in all three locations, with video facilities and some travel by staff and students used for connecting the teaching between the three sites.

Pembrokeshire’s Director of Education Kate Evan-Hughes, will be publishing a revised plan on 13 July and a meeting of the full council will decide three days later. What will she propose? Something along the following lines, I suggest. The site for the English-medium school in Haverfordwest will be moved to Tasker Millward. This is closer to Pembrokshire College and will enable some kind of amalgamated Sixth Form Centre to be shared between them. The Schools for the Future proposal for a new 3-16 school in St Davids, embracing the two primary schools in the town, will be accepted. There will also be a proposal for sixth form units to be kept at Fishguard and St Davids, but closely integrated with the new Sixth Form Centre in Haverfordwest.

Will this be a compromise acceptable to the warring factions that have been moblised on this hotly contested issue? Let us hope so. And let us remember, too, that school attainment is more an outcome achieved by good teachers and good leadership in our schools and not by reorganisations, however necessary.

Friday, 19 June 2015

Haven’s marine power opportunity


Last week’s announcement that the Department of the Energy and Climate Change is backing the proposed Tidal Lagoon in Swansea Bay could be momentous news for Pembrokeshire. If we play our cards right breathe new life will be breathed into Pembroke Dock which is well placed to become a hub for an entirely new industry.

Tidal Lagoon Power, the company that wants to build the £1billion lagoon off Swansea, says it will be a game changer for the renewable energy industry in Wales. If it goes ahead, and we will know for certain by the end of the year, it could be the first of six such lagoons off the Welsh coast, bringing an estimated 35,000 jobs over the next 15 years.
      
        The Swansea lagoon would produce enough renewable power for 155,000 homes for the next 120 years, supplying 90 per cent of Swansea Bay’s annual domestic energy use. It entails building a six-mile long seawall two miles out to sea from close to Swansea Docks, looping round and making landfall close to Swansea University's new Fabian Way campus to the east.
         
        The lagoon would house 16 underwater turbines generating electricity on both the rising and falling tide. And it’s the chance of assembling those turbines that provides Pembrokeshire with its opportunity. The hope is that engineering firms like Ledwood in Pembroke Dock will be well placed to help assemble the turbines whose parts are likely to be manufactured in Rugby. Ledwood took a hit from the closure of the Murco oil refinery last year. Its employees in Pembroke Dock have fallen from 1,000 at the peak to around 200. But the dawn of a new marine energy industry is offering fresh possibilities.

It’s good to learn that for once we’re ahead of the game with the creation of the Marine Energy Pembrokeshire partnership. This is bringing together technology developers, supply chain companies, the Welsh Government and others to proclaim what Pembrokeshire has to offer. Project Director David Jones says: “If you combine our natural resources with the grid connection possibilities, the transferable skills of the oil and gas industry supply chain, research links, the world class port facilities and the area’s designation as an energy Enterprise Zone, it all adds up to provide a very attractive package for developers.”

Of course, there have been false dawns promising economic revival for the Haven, not least the promise of oil discoveries in the Celtic Sea. But the potential for major marine energy developments off the western coast of Wales is much more tangible. The main hurdle is that Tidal Lagoon Power now has to negotiate with the UK government how much subsidy will be paid for the energy Swansea’s Tidal Lagoon will generate. And it is asking for a higher incentive than is presently given to wind turbines, solar power and nuclear. On the other hand the attraction for the government is the creation of a completely new industry with a massive economic impact.

In the past we missed the opportunity to develop the technology behind onshore wind and as a result the most valuable parts of onshore wind farms are imported. We must make sure that the same does not happen with marine renewables, and that Pembrokeshire takes full advantage of the opportunities that are now presenting themselves. 

Friday, 12 June 2015

Unfairness of the pesky parking tax


Few things are more calculated to provoke irritation and opposition in Pembrokeshire than car parking charges in our town centres. Witness the 8,893 people who signed a petition against them in St Thomas Green near the centre of Haverfordwest. Or the people from Goodwick who protested outside County Hall last week against proposals to charge in the town’s Station Hill car park.

Why is the opposition so intense in this part of Wales when elsewhere, especially in city centres like Cardiff and Swansea, charging for parking is long established and relatively uncontroversial? Pembrokeshire Council’s Head of Paid Services Ian Westley says its because nobody wants to pay for something they aren’t already paying. But it’s not that simple.

There’s a clue in one argument against the proposals to charge in St Dogmaels’ High Street. Local councillor Mike James said, “St Dogmaels is a village not a town and it is not somewhere where people come to shop or browse.” He added that the community was being treated like Narberth and Haverfordwest and that was not fair.

There is a sense in Pembrokeshire that all our villages and towns are in a similar position, certainly in comparison with large urban centres in southeast Wales. For instance, many people who pay for car parking in Cardiff are commuters or shoppers who live outside. For them parking fees operate as a congestion charge. And people who live close to or inside cities have a real alternative choice with public transport. If they’re over sixty they can use their free bus pass.

It’s not the same in rural Wales. Here many people have no choice but to travel by car. For them parking charges are in effect just another tax, and one that does not vary according to their ability to pay.

It is noteworthy that a while ago the Welsh Government stopped the NHS from imposing charges in hospital car parks. The argument was that it was unfair to impose charges on outpatients and people visiting friends or relatives in hospital. The same certainly applies in Goodwick where the Station Hill car park is widely used by patients at the adjoining Health Centre.

There’s another consideration, too. Many of our towns are run-down with shops boarded up, to a great extent the result of the poor planning by the county that has led to a rash of out-of-town developments. Imposing parking charges in town centres will only make this worse.

So what could be an alternative income for our cash-strapped council for which, as Ian Westley says, “every little helps”? How else could the council collect the £12m it hopes to raise from the proposed new parking charges? We urgently need to up-date the value of properties across the county, the basis upon which council tax is calculated. The last such re-valuation in Wales was in 2005. Since then the value of properties has risen considerably. An up-to-date re-evaluation would result in putting more properties into higher tax bands. It would mean asking the better off to pay a bit more. That would be a fairer way to raise the money Pembrokeshire needs.

Friday, 5 June 2015

Topsy turvy world of Welsh politics


Sometimes Welsh politics seem like a topsy turvy world. No so long ago the Conservatives were extremely hostile to the Welsh Assembly set up by Labour in Cardiff Bay. Today, however, it is they rather than Labour who are advocating more powers for the Assembly. Last week the Secretary of State for Wales, Preseli’s Conservative MP Stephen Crabb, said the Assembly should become a Parliament and take on responsibility for raising a significant proportion of the money it spends. “There is no parliament in any other part of the world that doesn’t have responsibility for raising money as well as spending it,” he said.

Stephen Crabb has come full circle on devolution. Writing in 2007 he declared, “Over the last ten years my opposition to devolution in Scotland and Wales has been driven by a belief that, far from satisfying the nationalist tendencies in these countries, devolution would foster and feed an increasingly separatist and socialist discourse in which sensible Conservative policies that could promote national cohesion, economic liberalism and smaller government would find little oxygen for survival.”

So what changed Mr Crabbe’s mind? The crucial factor was witnessing the debates in Scotland’s independence referendum, shortly after he became Secretary of State in July. This is how he explained it in a lecture to the Institute of Welsh Affairs, in Cardiff last November: “During the summer I visited Scotland three times to campaign alongside Conservative, Labour and Liberal Democrat activists to defend the Union. But I was reminded again on those visits just how far away Westminster is from the lives of most Scots. I stood inside the empty Parliament at Holyrood one afternoon with Ruth Davidson [the Scottish Conservative leader] and it struck me that this is no mere shadow of the Westminster Parliament; this is a full legislature in its own right; it is where Scots increasingly look for answers on so many of the issues they care about; and this Parliament is here to stay. And this growth in legitimacy and competence and authority is now unquestionably the path of our own Assembly – because the people of Wales have destined it to be so. I came away from Scotland on that Wednesday night before the Referendum absolutely certain that whatever the outcome the following night, nothing would ever be the same again in terms of our constitution.”

But the change Mr Crabb wants Wales to embrace is being fiercely resisted. The Welsh Labour Government is fearful that making Wales responsible for raising its own money will undermine the amount of the block grant it receives from London. This sum, it argues, is already inadequate and will be reduced even further by George Osborne’s spending cuts. Welsh Labour is also worried about going into a future election with the Welsh Conservatives promising tax cuts. In future these will be the dividing lines in Welsh politics. But don’t expect them to appear very soon. Before the Welsh Government can raise (or lower) taxation it has to get approval in a referendum.