Friday, 20 November 2015

Never ending tour of the Welsh Bob Dylan


Dafydd Iwan - never-ending tour
Dafydd Iwan’s Wales-wide fiftieth anniversary tour comes to Pembrokeshire next week. The troubadour, politician, businessman, language activist, architect, song-writer and lay-preacher will be giving one of his inimitable performances in Fishguard next Friday evening.

He started giving anniversary tours in the early 1980s with the band Ar Log (For Sale). These events have now become so frequent that one can say that like Bob Dylan, Dafydd Iwan is on a never ending tour. It has always seemed to me that he has a lot in common with Bob Dylan, though he insists it’s the American’s model of political protest rather than his music that has had most influence.

Dafydd Iwan first came to prominence in the 1960s as a student activist with  Cymdeithas yr Iaith (the Welsh Language Society), and especially its campaign for bilingual road signs. Peintio’r Byd yn Wyrdd (‘Painting the World Green’) was one of Dafydd’s most notable anthems of that era. He was ‘discovered’ by the television news programme Y Dydd (The Day) and given a weekly slot. As a result he became  “perhaps the first modern Welsh language singer to become a teenage idol”, to quote the sleeve of his first record in 1966.

He became chairman of Cymdeithas yr iaith between 1968 and 1971, one of the most dynamic periods in the Language Society’s history. This was due in part to its stand-off with George Thomas, the Labour Secretary of State for Wales who had adopted a stridently anti-language profile. In particular George Thomas ardently supported the Investiture of Prince Charles at Caernarfon Castle in 1969, which Cymdeithas yr Iaith opposed. Dafydd’s satirical anthem against the event was entitled ‘Carlo’.

Soon, however, he began a more conventional career on a number of fronts. He co-founded the record company Sain (Sound) which became a hugely successful business. Utilising his qualification as an architect he became involved with the Cymdeithas Tai Gwynedd housing association, dedicated to providing affordable homes for local people. And he switched from direct action campaigning to party politics. He stood as Plaid’s candidate in the two 1974 general elections in Anglesey, became an influential councillor in Plaid-controlled Gwynedd, and was eventually elected President of the party in 2003.

Dafydd was born and spent his early years in in Brynaman on the western edge of the southern coalfield. But when he was twelve his father, a nonconformist Minister, was called to be a pastor in the village of Llanuwchllyn near Bala. This upbringing gave Dafydd an instinctively national rather than local identity.  His was a family of nationalists in any event – grandfather Fred Jones, another Minister, was one of the founders of Plaid Cymru in 1925.


But what Dafydd’s 50th anniversary tour underlines is that throughout his career he has never ceased composing, recording and singing. Undoubtedly this has been his greatest influence and achievement. As the writer Simon Brooks once said, Dafydd’s songs have changed the cultural universe in which the Welsh people live.

Friday, 13 November 2015

A bad bet for Pembrokeshire


When I stood in the general election in Preseli last May one question I was frequently asked was what I thought about the European Union. This week Prime Minister Cameron has at last provided some substance to what he is trying to re-negotiate before the in/out referendum, likely to take place next year. So it is a good moment take stock of whether being part of the EU is good for Pembrokeshire.

I think that it is, for three reasons. First, in recent years we have benefited hugely from EU funding, initially the Objective 1 programme and now the continued Convergence funding which takes us until at least 2020. Take three examples: there has been £20m contributed by the EU towards the A40 by-pass around Robeston Wathen – more than half the £37m cost; Pembrokeshire County Council has received £5m towards its recycling programme; and Pembrokehshire Association of Voluntary Services has received £3m in the last few years to develop its activities.

 Robeston Wathen by-pass - brought £20 million EU funding to Pembrokeshire

The second reason is because the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy has been of enormous benefit to Pembrokeshire farmers. If Britain were to leave the EU I doubt that the Treasury in London – committed to reducing the amount of state spending - would give such priority to agricultural support.

And thirdly the consequences to the Pembrokeshire economy if we were to leave the EU would be dire. We would lose unfettered access to our main markets and there would be even less incentive for investment in new business to take place.

I was promoted to revisit these arguments by revelations last week by the shenanigans of some financiers in the City of London who are supporting the No campaign. I’m thinking of a number of very wealthy hedge fund managers who are looking to make a killing out of the stock market if, as they anticipate, it takes a dive following a No vote. These are some very unsavoury people indeed.

It’s worth taking a moment to understand the scheme they’re hatching known as ‘shorting’. Last week the US investment bank Morgan Stanley predicted that if the UK votes to come out of the EU, shares in the FTSE 100 could drop by as much as 20 per cent. For hedge fund managers that prospect has profit potential. Any predictable drastic movement in the shares of Britain’s biggest listed companies offers them scope for the following classic hedge fund manoeuvre. A fund ‘borrows’ shares from a City investor for a set period for a fee. The fund then sells the shares in the expectation of buying them back more cheaply when the price falls, and then returning them to the original owner.  The difference between the two prices is pocketed as profit by the hedge fund. That, in short, is ‘shorting’.


Can it be a coincidence then that a number of very prominent, and very rich owners of London hedge funds were reported last week as poised to give large sums to the Vote Leave campaign? This is seeking designation from the Electoral Commission as the official voice of the Out campaign. Amongst its backers is spread betting tycoon Stuart Wheeler, UKIP’s treasurer. It appears the No people are a betting crowd, but they’re a bad bet for Pembrokeshire.

Friday, 6 November 2015

Parent power should persuade council


In an extraordinary move last week the county council opened a new five-week consultation on its plans for the organisation of secondary schools in Haverfordwest. This followed the consultation on exactly the same issue that has taken place for most of this year and which has now been declared null and void. What is going on?

The Council wants to merge Sir Thomas Picton and Tasker Millward schools into a new English language secondary school and at the same time create a new Welsh medium secondary school in Haverfordwest. Most people agree that this.  However, the schools and most pupils and parents don’t agree with the Council’s proposals for taking away their sixth forms and creating a new Sixth Form Centre at Pembrokeshire College.

Indeed, there has been overwhelming and vehement opposition to this proposal. It's hard not to conclude that the Council’s main reason for re-opening the consultation for a much shorter period is a cynical mechanism to disregard this opposition.

It’s hard not to conclude, either, that the whole of the previous consultation was undertaken in bad faith. That’s because the Council had already made up its mind on the need for sixth form collaboration with Pembrokeshire College. Well before the consultation started last January the Council had forged links with the College to reorganise post-16 learning in Pembrokeshire as a whole, and not just Haverfordwest. Eventually, all Pembrokeshire’s post-16 funding would be routed through the college, which would also take responsibility for all 14-16 vocational learning. The local authority and the College commissioned a joint review which recommended the creation of a Sixth Form Centre. They then jointly appointed a transformation manager and an estates manager responsible for implementing the scheme.

But when they went out to consultation they ran into a brick wall of opposition in Haverfordwest and also in St David’s and Fishguard where parents were worried either by threats of schools closures or the removal of their sixth form. The local authority’s plans for centralising sixth form provision at Pembrokeshire College will also affect Milford Haven, Pembroke Dock and Tenby.

If the county council were to follow the responses they received in the last consultation they would do the following. They would establish a new 11-19 English-medium secondary school on the Sir Thomas Picton site and a new 11-16 Welsh-medium secondary school on the Tasker Millward site, making it clear that if there is demand after five years the latter will be extended to create a sixth form. Pembrokeshire College would focus on its primary purpose of providing excellent vocational courses, though pupils throughout the county would still be able to choose to study A-levels there. The secondary schools at St David’s and Fishguard would negotiate a federal arrangement with the new English-medium school in Haverfordwest to provide sixth form courses.


Is this argument about the best way to educate out children in Pembrokeshire? Or is it about shoring up the finances of Pembrokeshire College and about lightening the education responsibilities of the local authority? The Council now has a month to persuade us that the educational prospects of our children are uppermost in their thinking.



Friday, 30 October 2015

Stephen Crabb’s devolution dilemma


The Welsh Government runs Wales and the Westminster Government runs the UK. In his role as Secretary of State for Wales Preseli MP Stephen Crabb’s main job is to ensure effective co-operation between the two. At the moment he’s not doing too well.

Last week he published his draft Wales Bill that will devolve some new powers over energy, transport, and the organisation of elections. More importantly, it will fundamentally change the way legislative powers are devolved. Stephen Crabb’s intentions are good. He says he wants “a robust devolution settlement that works for the people of Wales.” So why are the other parties in the Assembly so strongly opposed to his proposals?

First Minster Carwyn Jones says the Bill amounts to an English veto on Welsh laws. He reckons that 14 of the 19 Bills the Assembly has passed since it acquired legislative powers would not have been possible under Stephen Crabb’s proposals. These include the ‘presumed consent’ system for organ donation that comes into force in December. “It means the Assembly not having a free hand in laws that have been devolved, without the consent of a Minister in Whitehall," according to Carwyn Jones. Meanwhile, the Presiding Officer Rosemary Butler has warned that unless the Wales Bill is changed substantially there will be calls for yet another one very soon.

As with most constitutional issues the devil is in the detail. Stephen Crabb describes the current system for devolving powers to the Assembly as “unstable and unclear” and he is right. In Scotland all functions are devolved apart from those that are reserved to Westminster such as defence and foreign affairs. On the other hand the National Assembly can only legislate where powers are specifically devolved. This has led to all manner of disputes about what the Assembly can and cannot do and has led UK Ministers and Welsh Ministers going to the courts on four expensive occasions to decide where power lies. 


Stephen Crabb wants Wales to have the Scottish system and in principle the other parties agree with him. The trouble is the legal processes of England and Wales are so deeply entangled that it is much more difficult to create the clear lines of responsibility that exist between London and Edinburgh. To do so would mean following Scotland by devolving responsibility for criminal and civil justice and creating a distinct legal jurisdiction.


But Stephen Crabb has set his face against this. In an interview with the Institute of Welsh Affairs’ journal Agenda this week he says he changed his mind about devolution as a result of the 2011 referendum, referring specifically his own constituency. "I didn't anticipate that people in Pembrokeshire were going to vote for full law-making powers for the Assembly in quite the way they did,” he said. “What that says is there has been a major shift in Welsh public sentiment about devolution since the first referendum in 1997.” However, it seems the shift is not enough for him to be brave enough to propose the stable and lasting devolution settlement he says he wants.

Friday, 23 October 2015

Wales needs a hydrogen highway


It is extraordinary to think that Wales was most connected internally and with the wider world a century ago, in the years leading up to World War I. In those days it was possible to travel from virtually any point in Wales to anywhere else of significant size by the main means of transport at the time – the railways. And as far as the wider world was concerned our major ports were connected with all points on the globe, with stocks of Welsh coal piled high in South America, Cape Town, China, Japan, and all points in between.

This was the high point of Welsh engagement with the wider world and it was no coincidence either that this was the most prosperous period in our history. It was also a high point for Welsh identity as well. The railways contributed significantly to the developing sense of Welsh nationhood in the golden Edwardian age.

Since then our communications have retreated to such an extent that we are now the most disconnected part of Britain, both within Wales as well as externally to the rest of the world. There is no doubt that this is contributing significantly to our economic problems.

This weekend I shall be speaking about this at Plaid Cymru’s conference in Aberystwyth. I will be seconding a motion being proposed by Cynog Dafis, the former AM and MP for Ceredigion and North Pembrokeshire, calling for a raft of policies to improve communications for Wales.

At present there is a tendency to link the north-east of Wales to Merseyside, mid Wales to the English Midlands, and the south-east to Bristol. Of course, we need good transport links with England to access the markets there for Welsh products. But we also need fast and effective links within Wales to counterbalance the pull to the east.

A glance at the Welsh road network reveals a ‘figure-of-eight’ pattern that links the four corners of the country. Improvements have been made to much of this network, though there remain significant gaps, for instance between Carmarthen and Aberystwyth. In any equivalent European country the network would be dual carriageway throughout. However, in Wales this is only the case along the east-west sections – the A55 across the northern coast, the M4 in the south and its extension to Carmarthen and St Clears– together with the A470 from Cardiff to Merthyr.

We should develop the ‘figure-of-eight’ spinal network by widening the roads to provide hard shoulders to give passing opportunities for faster moving traffic. These hard shoulders would also allow provision of a regular coach public transport service throughout the route. It should become known as a ‘Hydrogen Highway’ service with depots at regular intervals allowing the coaches to use this carbon friendly fuel.


Such innovative, practical and affordable policy thinking follows naturally from applying a national, one Wales perspective to our economic circumstances. That’s what we need, but it has been sadly lacking in Labour’s London-centric approach in the 16 long years it has been in charge of the Welsh Government.